Vermont Medicare Savings Program Denied: How to Appeal a QMB or QI Decision

The notice from DVHA says your parent's Medicare Savings Program application was denied — or their existing coverage is being terminated. The form letter cites an income over the limit, but you've counted the numbers and they don't add up. Vermont gives you 90 days to challenge the decision, and there's a way to keep benefits running while you do.

The 90-Day Appeal Window

Appeals go to the Human Services Board (HSB), an independent fair hearing body within the Agency of Human Services, at 6 Baldwin Street, Suite 305, Montpelier, VT 05633-4302. You must file within 90 days of the date stamped on the decision notice.

Four ways to file:

1. Online: Log into my.vermont.gov and submit a hearing request under "My Requests"
2. Phone: Call Green Mountain Care at 1-855-899-9600 or 1-800-250-8427
3. Email: Send to [email protected] with "Appeal" in the subject line
4. Mail: Write to the Human Services Board at the Montpelier address above

The Board must decide a standard appeal within 90 days of filing. If waiting would jeopardize your parent's health, request an expedited appeal — the Board decides those within 7 working days.

Keeping Benefits While You Appeal

This is the critical piece most families miss. If your parent's existing MSP or VPharm coverage is being terminated (not a new application denial), you can request "Aid Paid Pending" — continuation of benefits during the appeal. The request must be filed before the effective date of closure listed on the termination notice.

If the Board rules against your parent, they may technically owe back the benefits received during the appeal period. But the alternative — losing Part B premium payment and QMB protections during a months-long appeal — is far worse for most families.

For a new application denial, Aid Paid Pending doesn't apply because there were no existing benefits to continue.

Common Denial Reasons and What to Check

Income miscalculation. DVHA counts gross Social Security before the Part B deduction. But the $20 general income disregard should be applied. If the denial notice shows your parent's income at $2,005 and the QMB limit is $1,995, check whether the $20 disregard was properly applied — $2,005 minus $20 equals $1,985, which qualifies.

Household composition. Since April 2026, the Dependent Relative Rule allows qualifying relatives who depend on your parent for 50% or more of their support to be counted in the household. A larger household means a higher income threshold. If DVHA calculated eligibility for a household of one when a dependent relative lives with your parent, the income limit may have been set too low.

Missing documents. Some denials result from incomplete applications rather than actual ineligibility. Check whether the notice cites missing verification — a Social Security award letter, a pension statement, a signature — and whether submitting the missing item would resolve the issue faster than a formal appeal.

Free Legal Help

The Office of the Health Care Advocate (HCA), run by Vermont Legal Aid, provides free counseling and direct representation before the Human Services Board. Call 1-800-917-7787 or visit vtlawhelp.org/health. The HCA can review the denial notice, identify errors in the income calculation, and represent your parent at the hearing at no cost.

The Vermont Medicare Savings Programs, Extra Help & VPharm Guide walks through the appeal process from notice review through hearing preparation, including a deadline calendar and tips for documenting the income disregard calculation.

See more Vermont guides →