Public Trustee vs Public Guardian Australia

When a tribunal appoints someone to manage your parent's affairs, you'll hear two titles that sound almost identical but cover completely different territory. Getting them confused can mean paying thousands in fees you didn't expect — or worse, losing the right to make decisions you assumed were yours.

Two Separate Roles, Two Separate Appointments

The Public Trustee (called State Trustees in Victoria) handles your parent's money. Bank accounts, investments, bill payments, property sales, tax returns — anything financial. If a tribunal appoints the Public Trustee, they manage the financial matters covered by the order.

The Public Guardian (called the Office of the Public Advocate in some states) handles your parent's personal and lifestyle decisions. Where they live, what medical treatment they receive, who can visit them, what daily services they access. If a tribunal appoints the Public Guardian, they make these decisions instead of family.

These are two entirely separate legal appointments. A tribunal can appoint one without the other. A family member might be appointed as financial administrator while the Public Guardian handles lifestyle decisions, or vice versa.

What Public Trustee Fees Actually Look Like

This is where families get blindsided. Tribunal applications are free across every state and territory. But the ongoing costs of state-managed financial administration are substantial.

Victoria (State Trustees): Charges an asset management commission on a sliding scale — roughly 3.3% on assets up to $500,000. Urgent temporary order administration incurs an hourly fee of $216.

Queensland (Public Trustee): Annual management fees typically range between 5% and 6% of the managed estate's gross value.

Western Australia: Private administrators appointed by the tribunal face mandatory account audits by the Public Trustee at $354 per hour, with a minimum charge of $354.

Tasmania: A capital commission on a sliding scale — up to 4.5% on the first $200,000 of assets collected or sold, plus a 6.6% income commission on all income received.

For a parent with a $600,000 home and $200,000 in savings, these commissions can run to tens of thousands of dollars over the administration period. That money comes directly from your parent's estate.

When Tribunals Bypass Family

Tribunals appoint state officials instead of family members in three main scenarios. First, when there's active family conflict — siblings fighting over care decisions, step-parents disputing asset management, or allegations of elder abuse. Second, when no family member is willing or geographically able to take on the role. Third, when a family member has previously been removed as attorney for misconduct.

The tribunal's mandate is "least restrictive" intervention. They generally prefer a suitable family appointment where possible, consistent with that principle, if the family can demonstrate they'll work together and act in the parent's best interests.

How to Avoid State Appointment

The single most effective protection is executing enduring documents while your parent still has capacity. An enduring power of attorney lets your parent choose their own financial attorney. An enduring guardianship (or its state equivalent) lets them choose their own personal decision-maker.

These documents bypass the tribunal entirely. No application, no hearing, no ongoing state oversight, and no commission fees.

If your parent has already lost capacity and you're facing a tribunal application, present a unified family position. Agree among siblings on who will serve as administrator and guardian before the hearing. Tribunals strongly favour family applicants who arrive with a clear, conflict-free plan.

The Enduring Power of Attorney and Guardianship toolkit walks through every state's instrument requirements and tribunal application process — so you can either set up private appointments before capacity is lost, or present the strongest possible family case at a tribunal hearing.

See more Australia guides →