$0 IRMAA Life-Changing Event: Evidence Checklist for Form SSA-44

SSA-44 Estimated Income: How to Fill Out Step 2 and Step 3

The Part Most People Get Wrong

Step 2 and Step 3 of Form SSA-44 are where the actual numbers go — your estimated Modified Adjusted Gross Income for the years SSA will use to recalculate your surcharge. These two boxes determine whether your IRMAA drops, disappears, or stays the same.

The form asks for a MAGI estimate, not your exact tax return. You're projecting income for a year that may not be over yet. Getting the number reasonably close matters: SSA will compare your estimate against your actual IRS return once it's filed, and if the real figure lands you in a higher bracket, you'll owe the difference.

Which Year Goes in Step 2

Step 2 asks for information from a more recent year than the tax return data SSA used. For a 2026 premium adjustment, choose the premium year if your MAGI for that year will be lower than the prior year's; otherwise choose the preceding year.

Event occurred before the current premium year (e.g., you retired in 2025 and you're filing in 2026):

  • Use the current premium year (2026) if your 2026 MAGI will be lower than the preceding year's (2025)
  • Otherwise use the preceding year (2025)

Event occurred during the current premium year (e.g., you retired in March 2026):

  • Use the current premium year (2026) — it captures the full post-event income picture

In practice, most retirees filing for a work stoppage will put the first full post-retirement year in Step 2, because that year reflects their genuinely reduced income.

Which Year Goes in Step 3

Step 3 is for the following year — one year after whatever you entered in Step 2. Complete it only if next year's MAGI is expected to be even lower than the Step 2 year.

If your income is stable in retirement (pension plus Social Security, no major changes expected), skip Step 3. SSA automatically carries the Step 2 estimate forward into the next premium year.

If you expect a further drop — say you're winding down consulting income or a pension reduction takes full effect mid-year — enter the lower estimate in Step 3.

Free Download

Get the IRMAA Life-Changing Event: Evidence Checklist for Form SSA-44

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Calculating Your MAGI Estimate

MAGI for IRMAA purposes has a specific definition:

Estimated MAGI = Adjusted Gross Income (1040 Line 11) + Tax-Exempt Interest (1040 Line 2a)

This is narrower than the MAGI definitions used for Medicaid, the Health Insurance Marketplace, or SSI. You're adding exactly two numbers from your 1040.

Build the estimate by totaling each income stream you expect for the year:

  • Taxable pension and annuity income (1099-R distributions)
  • Social Security benefits — only the taxable portion counts (already included in Line 11 AGI)
  • Taxable traditional IRA and 401(k) withdrawals (including taxable Required Minimum Distributions)
  • Remaining employment income if you worked part of the year
  • Taxable interest, dividends, and capital gains
  • Net rental or business income
  • Tax-exempt interest (municipal bonds — the Line 2a add-back)

Do not include Roth IRA qualified distributions (they don't appear in AGI), Health Savings Account distributions used exclusively for qualified medical expenses, or the nontaxable return of basis from non-qualified annuities.

Round conservatively. It's better to overestimate slightly than to underestimate and face a retroactive adjustment when SSA reconciles against your real return.

A Worked Example

Joan retired from teaching in June 2025. Her 2024 MAGI (full salary year) was $135,000, putting her in the second IRMAA tier — an extra $81.20/month on Part B and $14.50 on Part D.

She files SSA-44 in January 2026 with "work stoppage" checked.

Step 2 (2026): Full-year pension ($36,000) + Social Security ($25,900 taxable) + tax-exempt interest ($2,800) = estimated MAGI of $64,700. This is lower than her 2025 MAGI, so she uses 2026 in Step 2. It is below the $109,000 single threshold — no IRMAA.

Step 3 (2027): If Joan does not expect her 2027 MAGI to be lower than $64,700, she leaves this blank. SSA will carry the Step 2 estimate forward for the next year.

SSA processes the request and removes Joan's surcharge retroactive to January 2026. Any premiums she already overpaid are credited back through her Social Security benefit check.

Common Mistakes

  • Including gross income instead of net: rental income is net of expenses; business income is net profit. Gross receipts inflate your estimate.
  • Forgetting tax-exempt interest: this is the number-one surprise. Municipal bond income counts toward IRMAA even though it's not taxable.
  • Double-counting Social Security: your taxable Social Security is already part of AGI on Line 11. Don't add your gross benefit on top.
  • Leaving Step 3 blank when income is dropping further: if next year will be lower, filling in Step 3 locks in the lower determination for two premium years instead of one.

Get the Full Worksheet

Our SSA-44 guide includes a MAGI estimation worksheet that maps every income line to the form, plus three worked dollar examples — retirement, widowhood, and pension loss — with the arithmetic checked against the 2026 bracket thresholds.

Get Your Free IRMAA Life-Changing Event: Evidence Checklist for Form SSA-44

Download the IRMAA Life-Changing Event: Evidence Checklist for Form SSA-44 — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →