Patient Rights During Hospital Discharge in Minnesota

Hospitals Cannot Just Push You Out the Door

When a hospital discharge planner tells you your parent is being sent home tomorrow, it feels like a directive with no recourse. It is not. Federal Medicare regulations and Minnesota state law give patients and their families specific, enforceable rights during the discharge process — and most families never learn about them until after the discharge has already happened.

The core protection: Medicare beneficiaries have the right to receive a safe discharge plan, to be informed about their discharge in writing, and to appeal eligible discharge decisions they believe are premature or unsafe. These Medicare rights apply to Original Medicare and Medicare Advantage; Medical Assistance is a separate program with its own coverage and state appeal rights.

The Written Notices You Must Receive

For a Medicare inpatient, hospitals must deliver specific written notices before or during the discharge process; which notices and deadlines apply depends on the patient's coverage and inpatient or observation status:

"An Important Message from Medicare" (IM). Every Medicare inpatient must receive this notice within two days of admission and before discharge. It explains the patient's right to appeal a discharge and includes instructions for contacting Commence Health, Minnesota's designated Beneficiary and Family Centered Care Quality Improvement Organization (BFCC-QIO). If the initial IM was provided more than two days before discharge, the hospital must provide a second copy before discharge for the patient's signature; the rule does not require that second copy to be issued four hours before discharge.

Medicare Outpatient Observation Notice (MOON). If the patient has been under observation status for more than 24 hours, the hospital must deliver this notice explaining that the patient is classified as outpatient rather than inpatient.

Medicare Change of Status Notice (MCSN, Form CMS-10868). Effective February 14, 2025, hospitals must issue this notice to eligible Original Medicare patients when they change a patient's status from inpatient to outpatient observation. The MCSN creates a formal right to appeal the status change through Commence Health.

Can a Hospital Force Discharge?

A hospital cannot physically remove a patient who is medically unstable. But the practical pressure is real — discharge planners work under institutional incentives to free beds, and they can be aggressive about timelines.

Here is what a hospital can do: declare that the patient no longer meets inpatient medical necessity criteria, issue the discharge notices, and set a discharge date. If the patient or family does nothing in response, the discharge proceeds.

Here is what they cannot do: discharge a patient while a formal appeal is pending with Commence Health. Once you file an expedited appeal, the hospital must keep the patient and continue care until an independent physician completes a review and issues a determination. This automatic stay of discharge is the most powerful protection families have, and it costs nothing to invoke.

How to Refuse or Appeal a Discharge

If you believe the discharge is premature or unsafe:

Step 1: Ask the discharge planner for a copy of the "Important Message from Medicare" notice. Review it to confirm the appeal instructions and Commence Health's contact information.

Step 2: Call Commence Health at 1-888-524-9900 to file an expedited appeal. The call must happen by noon on the day of the planned discharge, or before the patient physically leaves the hospital. When you call, provide the patient's Medicare Beneficiary Identifier and a clear statement of why the discharge is unsafe — ongoing pain management needs, wound care requirements, fall risk, or cognitive issues that make independent functioning dangerous.

Step 3: Once the appeal is filed, the hospital cannot discharge the patient or bill the family for the continued stay while the QIO reviews the case. Commence Health will request the patient's medical records, consult with an independent physician, and issue a binding determination, typically within 24 to 48 hours.

If the QIO rules in the patient's favor, the hospital must develop a safer, more appropriate discharge or transition plan. If the QIO upholds the hospital's decision, the patient may become financially responsible for services provided after the coverage end date.

Medicare Advantage Plans Have a Separate Track

Patients enrolled in Medicare Advantage plans have the same right to appeal, but the process has an additional layer. The MA plan may issue its own coverage determination before the QIO gets involved. If the plan denies continued coverage, the patient can still escalate to Commence Health for an independent review.

The critical difference: Medicare Advantage plans may also impose prior authorization requirements on post-acute placements, meaning the discharge planner's recommended rehab facility might not be in-network. If your parent is on an Advantage plan, verify network status before agreeing to any facility transfer.

Minnesota-Specific Protections Beyond Medicare

Minnesota law adds protections beyond the federal Medicare framework. The state's patient rights protections require hospitals to involve patients and their designated representatives in discharge planning and document relevant preferences for post-acute care. A hospital may still recommend a setting based on clinical needs, availability, and coverage; ask for alternatives and the reason for the recommendation.

For patients transitioning to a nursing home, Minnesota Statute 144.6501 protects family members from being forced to sign as personal financial guarantors during the admission process — a common pressure tactic that many families face within hours of a hospital discharge.

The Minnesota Hospital Discharge Guide includes the complete appeal scripts, deadline trackers, and home safety checklists that help families exercise these rights without scrambling for information in the middle of a crisis.

See more Minnesota guides →