Indiana Living Will vs Healthcare Representative

Indiana Merged These Into One Document — and Most Families Don't Know

If you're searching for the difference between a living will and a healthcare representative appointment in Indiana, the answer has changed dramatically since 2021. Under Senate Enrolled Act 204, Indiana retired both documents as standalone instruments and consolidated them into a single form: the Advance Directive for Health Care Decisions under IC § 16-36-7.

Before the change, Indiana had three separate healthcare planning tools:

• The healthcare power of attorney (under IC § 30-5-5-16), which designated someone to make medical decisions
• The appointment of healthcare representative (under IC § 16-36-1-7), which designated a decision-maker for specific healthcare situations
• The living will declaration (under IC § 16-36-4-10), which documented end-of-life treatment preferences

Each had its own execution rules, its own statutory framework, and its own potential for confusion. Families would execute a living will thinking it covered everything, not realizing they also needed a separate healthcare representative appointment. Or they'd have a healthcare power of attorney that didn't address end-of-life wishes, leaving providers uncertain about the family's intentions during a crisis.

The unified Advance Directive eliminates those gaps by combining all three functions into one instrument.

What the Advance Directive Covers

A properly executed Indiana Advance Directive lets your parent:

Appoint Healthcare Representatives. Your parent can name a primary representative and one or more successors who step in if the primary person is unavailable or unable to serve. The representative has authority to make medical decisions, consult with healthcare providers, and access protected health information — all in a single designation.

Document Treatment Preferences. The Advance Directive replaces the old living will by allowing your parent to specify what medical treatments they want or don't want under various conditions. This includes preferences about life-sustaining treatment, artificial nutrition and hydration, mechanical ventilation, and comfort care measures. These instructions guide both the healthcare representative and the medical team.

Address Anatomical Gifts. Your parent can document organ, tissue, or body donation preferences directly in the Advance Directive.

Include Funeral Planning. The document can incorporate a funeral planning declaration, specifying burial vs. cremation preferences and other post-death arrangements.

Execution Requirements Under IC § 16-36-7-28

The execution rules for an Advance Directive are specific, and getting them wrong can invalidate the entire document.

The Advance Directive must be in writing, dated, and signed by the declarant (or by someone signing on their behalf, in their presence and at their express direction, if the declarant is physically unable to sign). It then must be validated in one of two ways:

Option 1 — Two Witnesses: Two adult witnesses must sign in the declarant's presence. At least one witness must not be the declarant's spouse or blood relative.

Option 2 — Notary Public: The declarant signs or acknowledges the document in the presence of a notary, who attaches a standard notarial certificate.

Indiana also accommodates remote execution. If physical distance or health isolation prevents in-person signing, the declarant and witnesses (or notary) can interact through real-time audiovisual technology. Alternatively, the document can be signed in separate paper counterparts that are combined into a single composite document within ten business days of the final signature.

Telephonic execution is permitted for witnesses under specific circumstances — the witnesses must be able to positively identify the declarant, confirm their capacity, and include explicit language in the document stating that telephonic interaction was used. But telephonic notarization is strictly prohibited.

What Happens Without an Advance Directive

If your parent loses the capacity to make healthcare decisions and hasn't executed an Advance Directive, Indiana defaults to a statutory proxy hierarchy under IC § 16-36-1-5. Medical decisions fall to:

1. A judicially appointed guardian (if one exists)
2. The spouse (unless legally separated or divorce is pending)
3. Adult children (if multiple exist, the provider must seek consent from a majority of those reasonably available)
4. Parents
5. Adult siblings
6. Other surviving adult relatives of the next closest degree

The hierarchy works in theory, but in practice it creates delays and conflicts. If three adult children disagree about whether to authorize surgery, the hospital has to determine who constitutes the "majority of those reasonably available." If a sibling hasn't spoken to the family in years but technically has equal standing to the primary caregiver, the decision-making process stalls.

An Advance Directive eliminates all of this by putting one designated person in charge, with clear succession if that person can't serve.

Old Documents Still Work — But With Limitations

If your parent executed a healthcare power of attorney or a living will declaration before the 2021 consolidation, those documents remain legally valid. Indiana didn't invalidate existing instruments. But they only cover what they were designed to cover:

• A pre-2021 healthcare power of attorney designates a decision-maker but may not include treatment preferences or end-of-life instructions
• A pre-2021 living will addresses end-of-life wishes but doesn't appoint anyone to make decisions about non-terminal conditions

If your parent has one of these older documents, consider executing a new unified Advance Directive to fill the gaps. The new document supersedes the old one once properly executed.

Practical Steps for Families

Don't wait for a diagnosis. An Advance Directive is most valuable when signed while your parent is clearly competent. If dementia or cognitive decline has begun, the window for valid execution narrows — your parent must understand what they're signing and the implications of delegating healthcare authority.

Choose the representative carefully. The person your parent names will make life-and-death decisions during a crisis. They should be someone who understands your parent's values, can handle pressure, is geographically accessible (or at least reachable by phone), and is willing to advocate firmly with medical staff.

Distribute copies. Give copies to your parent's primary care physician, their specialist providers, the local hospital, any care facility they use, and each family member involved in caregiving. Keep the original in a secure but accessible location — not a safe deposit box that requires a key and a trip to the bank during an emergency.

Pair it with a durable financial POA. The Advance Directive covers healthcare decisions. It doesn't give anyone authority to manage bank accounts, pay bills, or handle financial matters. A durable financial power of attorney under IC § 30-5 covers that side. Together, the two documents provide comprehensive authority without court involvement.

Our Indiana Power of Attorney & Guardianship Kit walks through both documents with the current execution rules, including the post-2024 notary and witness requirements for the financial POA. Having both in place before a crisis is the single most effective thing you can do to protect your parent's wishes and your family's sanity.

See more Indiana guides →