Sibling Dispute Over Power of Attorney in Virginia — Legal Rights and Resolution

Your sister has power of attorney for your mother. She won't return your calls about the finances. Bills are going unpaid. You suspect money is being moved to accounts you can't see. But you're not the agent — so what can you actually do?

Sibling disputes over a parent's power of attorney are among the most painful situations in eldercare. They combine genuine concern for the parent, family resentment, and complicated legal authority into a conflict that often escalates beyond reason. Virginia law provides specific mechanisms for addressing POA abuse, but it also respects the parent's original choice of agent.

What the Non-Agent Sibling Can Do

Virginia Code § 64.2-1614 grants specific standing to interested parties — which includes the principal's adult children — to petition the circuit court to:

• Compel an accounting. The court can order the agent to produce a complete record of every financial transaction conducted under the power of attorney.
• Review the agent's conduct. The court can evaluate whether the agent is acting in the principal's best interest and complying with their fiduciary duties.
• Remove the agent. If the court finds the agent has breached their fiduciary duty, mismanaged assets, or acted against the principal's interests, the agent can be removed and replaced.
• Terminate the power of attorney entirely. In extreme cases, the court can void the POA and require the family to pursue guardianship/conservatorship.

Filing this petition requires hiring an attorney and paying filing fees. It's not a casual step — but it's a real legal remedy when genuine abuse is occurring.

The Agent's Fiduciary Duties

Every power of attorney agent in Virginia is bound by fiduciary duties under Virginia Code § 64.2-1612. The agent must:

• Act in the principal's best interest — not their own, not another family member's
• Keep personal and principal funds completely separate — no commingling bank accounts
• Maintain records of every transaction conducted under the POA
• Act within the scope of authority granted by the document
• Preserve the principal's estate plan to the extent reasonably possible

Violating these duties is not just a civil matter. Under Virginia Code § 18.2-178.2, financial exploitation of an incapacitated adult — including by a POA agent — is a criminal offense. If the exploited assets exceed $1,000, it's a felony.

Common Dispute Scenarios and Legal Options

"My sibling won't show me the finances." An agent is not required by statute to provide regular financial updates to other family members — their duty runs to the principal, not to siblings. However, if the principal is incapacitated and can't review the agent's actions, the practical effect is zero oversight. The remedy is a court petition for an accounting.

"I think my sibling is spending our parent's money on themselves." Document everything you can observe — unpaid bills, late property tax notices, changes to the home's condition, new purchases your sibling has made. Then consult an elder law attorney about filing under § 64.2-1614 or reporting to Adult Protective Services.

"The POA was signed when my parent was already too confused to understand it." If your parent lacked capacity when the POA was executed, the document may be invalid. You can challenge the POA's validity in circuit court. A contemporaneous medical evaluation (or lack thereof) from the signing date will be key evidence. If the POA is invalidated and your parent currently lacks capacity, the court will need to appoint a guardian and/or conservator.

"My parent named the wrong sibling." This is harder to address if the parent had capacity when they signed. Virginia law respects the principal's choice of agent. If the agent is fulfilling their duties and acting in the parent's interest, a court won't remove them simply because you disagree with the selection. The path forward is documenting actual breaches of duty — not personal disagreements about care decisions.

Preventing Disputes Before They Start

If you're the agent, the best defense against sibling accusations is transparency:

• Set up view-only bank access for other siblings so they can see account activity without having transaction authority
• Send quarterly financial summaries showing income, expenses, and account balances
• Document every significant decision — why you chose a particular care facility, why you authorized a procedure, why you hired an aide
• Keep your parent's money in a separate account from your own — never commingle, not even temporarily
• If you pay yourself for caregiving, get it documented and approved. Many POAs allow reasonable compensation, but undisclosed payments look like theft to a suspicious sibling.

If you're the non-agent sibling, the best approach before litigation is direct communication:

• Request financial updates in writing — email creates a record
• Attend medical appointments when possible to stay informed about care decisions
• Propose a family care meeting to discuss the parent's needs and the agent's approach
• Raise specific concerns, not accusations — "I noticed the property tax hasn't been paid" gets a better response than "I think you're stealing"

When to Escalate

There's a difference between a sibling dispute and genuine financial abuse. Escalate to legal action or APS when:

• The parent's basic needs aren't being met (utilities shut off, medical bills unpaid, home in disrepair) despite sufficient income or assets
• The agent is transferring assets to themselves or others without apparent benefit to the parent
• The agent is isolating the parent from other family members
• The parent is expressing fear or distress about the agent's behavior (even if they can't articulate it clearly due to cognitive decline)
• Bank statements show patterns of unexplained withdrawals or new signers on accounts

These situations warrant more than family mediation. Report to Adult Protective Services (Virginia hotline: 1-888-832-3858) and consult with an elder law attorney about court remedies.

The Virginia Power of Attorney & Guardianship Kit includes the fiduciary duty framework and transparency protocols that help POA agents document their decisions and protect themselves against false accusations — and the guardianship filing guide for families who need to move beyond the POA to court-supervised oversight.

See more Virginia guides →