Nonmedical Home Care vs Home Health in South Dakota: What's the Difference?
Why the Distinction Matters
Families in South Dakota routinely confuse "home care" and "home health," and the mix-up creates real problems. You ask your parent's doctor about getting help at home, they order home health through Medicare, and six weeks later the physical therapist is discharged because the skilled need is resolved — but your parent still can't cook, bathe, or manage medications safely. That's because you needed nonmedical home care, and nobody explained the difference.
These are two entirely separate systems with different licensing, different funding, and different purposes.
Nonmedical Home Care: Daily Living Support
Nonmedical home care covers the practical, hands-on help your parent needs to function safely at home day after day:
- Bathing, dressing, and grooming assistance
- Meal preparation and feeding help
- Light housekeeping and laundry
- Medication reminders (not administration)
- Companionship and supervision
- Transportation to appointments and errands
- Toileting and incontinence care
For private-pay nonmedical home care, no physician's order is generally required. Caregivers are typically personal care aides or home health aides without clinical licenses. The service is ongoing — as many hours per week as your parent needs, for as long as they need it.
Funding: Private pay (roughly $6,500–$8,500/month for full-time nonmedical help), Medicaid HOPE Waiver (homemaker and personal care services), or Medicaid Personal Care Services (PCS) state plan benefit. Medicare does not cover nonmedical home care.
Home Health Care: Short-Term Clinical Treatment
Home health care is a medical service: skilled nursing, physical therapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy, and wound care delivered in the home by licensed clinicians. It requires a physician's order and a plan of care (the CMS-485 form).
In South Dakota, home health agencies are licensed by the Department of Health under the Administrative Rules of South Dakota (ARSD) and must be Medicare-certified.
Key characteristics:
- The patient must be "homebound" — meaning leaving home requires a taxing effort or creates a health risk
- Services are intermittent and goal-oriented (typically 2–3 visits per week)
- The objective is recovery or stabilization, not indefinite maintenance
- Treatment is time-limited — usually 60-day certification periods, renewable as long as skilled need continues
Funding: Medicare Part A covers home health with no copay or deductible when the homebound and skilled-need criteria are met. Medicaid covers it for those who qualify financially. Private insurance may also cover it.
Free Download
Get the South Dakota — Aging in Place Resource Checklist
Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Nonmedical Home Care | Home Health Care | |
|---|---|---|
| Purpose | Daily living support, ongoing | Clinical treatment, recovery-focused |
| Who provides it | Personal care aides, homemakers | Licensed nurses, physical/occupational/speech therapists |
| Doctor's order needed | No | Yes |
| Duration | Ongoing, no time limit | Intermittent, 60-day certification periods |
| Medicare covers it | No | Yes (if homebound + skilled need) |
| Medicaid covers it | Yes (HOPE Waiver or PCS) | Yes |
| Private-pay cost | $6,500–$8,500/month for full-time nonmedical help | Varies by clinical units billed |
| Typical start timeline | 2–4 weeks | 1–3 days post-referral |
The Handoff Problem
The scenario that catches families off guard is the post-hospital transition. Your parent falls, gets hip surgery, spends three days in the hospital and two weeks in rehab. The hospital discharge planner sets up Medicare home health — a physical therapist comes three times a week and a nurse checks the surgical site.
Six weeks later, home health discharges your parent because they've met their therapy goals and the wound is healed. But your parent still can't safely get in and out of the shower, still forgets medications, still can't prepare meals. That's the handoff point where nonmedical home care needs to start, and there's no automatic system to make it happen.
If you anticipate ongoing daily needs beyond the recovery period, start the Dakota at Home intake process (1-833-663-9673) during the home health episode — don't wait until discharge. The LTSS assessment and Medicaid application can process in parallel with the clinical recovery.
Which One Does Your Parent Need?
Your parent needs home health if they're recovering from surgery, a fall, or a hospitalization and need skilled nursing or therapy at home. Their doctor will order it and Medicare will likely cover it.
Your parent needs nonmedical home care if they have chronic, progressive difficulty with daily activities — bathing, dressing, cooking, managing medications — and need reliable, ongoing help to stay safely at home.
Your parent may need both simultaneously — and that's common. Home health handles the clinical piece while nonmedical home care handles everything else. Medicare covers the home health; you'll fund the nonmedical care through private pay, the HOPE Waiver, or Medicaid PCS.
The South Dakota Home Care Navigator maps out both pathways and shows how to run them in parallel, so nothing falls through the gap when home health ends and long-term home care needs to begin.
Get Your Free South Dakota — Aging in Place Resource Checklist
Download the South Dakota — Aging in Place Resource Checklist — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.