Appeal Care Funding Decision Wales: How to Challenge CHC and Social Care Denials

Your parent's been refused NHS Continuing Healthcare or the financial assessment feels wrong, and you're furious. Good — that energy matters, because the appeal system in Wales actually works if you know the steps and the deadlines. Families who challenge CHC decisions in Wales succeed more often than they expect, and the process costs nothing.

Appealing a CHC Decision: The Two-Stage Process

If the Local Health Board (LHB) decides your parent doesn't have a "primary health need" and denies CHC funding, you have a structured appeal route.

Stage 1: Local Review. Write to the LHB within 28 days of receiving the decision letter. State clearly that you're requesting a local review and explain why you disagree with the Decision Support Tool (DST) scoring. Focus on specific domains where you believe the MDT underscored your parent's needs — for example, if they scored "Moderate" in behaviour but your parent requires constant supervision for aggression or wandering.

The LHB convenes a review panel that re-examines the evidence. You can submit additional medical notes, care home daily records, or GP letters that support higher domain scores. Request a copy of the completed DST and the MDT's written rationale — you're entitled to both.

Stage 2: Independent Review Panel (IRP). If the local review upholds the denial, you can request an Independent Review Panel. This must be requested within 6 months of the original decision. The IRP is convened by the LHB but includes independent clinical assessors who weren't involved in the original decision. Families can attend and present their case directly.

The IRP doesn't make a binding decision — it makes a recommendation to the LHB. However, LHBs that ignore IRP recommendations face escalation to the Public Services Ombudsman for Wales, so the recommendation carries real weight.

Challenging the Financial Assessment

If your dispute is with the local authority's means test calculation rather than a CHC decision, the route is different.

Internal review. Request an officer review within the Financial Assessment Team. Common errors include: counting the mobility component of PIP/DLA as income (it should be fully disregarded), failing to account for Disability-Related Expenditure, not applying the 50% pension share for a spouse at home, or miscalculating the Minimum Income Amount.

Formal complaint. If the internal review doesn't resolve it, submit a formal complaint through the local authority's two-stage complaints procedure under the Social Services Complaints (Wales) Regulations. Stage 1 is a local investigation by a complaints officer, with a response target of 15 working days. Stage 2 is an independent investigation.

Getting Free Advocacy: Llais

Llais is the independent body that replaced Community Health Councils in Wales. They provide free advocacy and complaints support for anyone navigating the NHS in Wales. For CHC appeals, Llais can:

• Help you understand the DST scoring and identify where domains were underscored
• Attend MDT meetings and review panels alongside you
• Draft formal complaint and appeal letters
• Escalate unresolved disputes to the Ombudsman

Contact Llais through their website or by calling their helpline. You don't need a referral, and their services are completely free regardless of your income.

The Public Services Ombudsman for Wales

The Ombudsman is the final escalation point for both NHS and social care complaints. You can approach the Ombudsman if:

• The LHB has completed its internal complaints process and you're still dissatisfied
• The local authority has completed both stages of its complaints procedure
• The complaint involves maladministration (procedural failures, unreasonable delays, or failure to follow statutory guidance)

The Ombudsman can investigate, make findings, and require the NHS or local authority to take corrective action. Investigations are free and you can submit your complaint online, by post, or by phone.

Evidence That Wins Appeals

The families who succeed in care funding appeals do two things consistently:

Keep contemporaneous records. Daily care logs from the care home, medication charts, incident reports, behavioural charts, and hospital discharge summaries are far more persuasive than retrospective descriptions. Request copies of your parent's care home daily notes — you're entitled to them.

Challenge domain scoring with specifics. Don't write "my mother's needs are more severe than the assessment shows." Write: "The DST scored my mother as Moderate in Continence, but the care home records show 4-6 episodes of incontinence per day requiring full assistance, which meets the criteria for High."

Retrospective CHC Claims

If your parent was in a care home paying privately at a time when they should have qualified for CHC, you may be able to claim a retrospective refund. Welsh LHBs must consider backdated claims, and specialist solicitors like Hugh James have recovered over £250 million in care fees for families across England and Wales since 2006.

Retrospective claims are complex and typically require professional legal help. Most specialist firms work on a contingency basis — you pay nothing unless they recover fees, though success fees of 25% plus VAT are standard. For families who've paid tens of thousands in private care fees that should have been NHS-funded, the potential recovery easily outweighs the cost.

Deadlines to Remember

• 28 days to request a local review of a CHC decision
• 6 months to request an Independent Review Panel after the original decision
• 12 months to refer an unresolved complaint to the Public Services Ombudsman (though the Ombudsman can accept later referrals in exceptional circumstances)
• No statutory deadline for retrospective CHC claims, but evidence degrades over time — act as early as possible

The Wales Care Funding Guide includes CHC appeal letter templates, a DST self-scoring checklist, and a complaint timeline tracker designed for the Welsh system — giving you the structure to challenge unfair decisions systematically.

See more Wales guides →