How to Choose a Nursing Home in Tennessee Without Using a Referral Service

You don't need A Place for Mom, CarePatrol, or any commission-based referral service to find a good nursing home in Tennessee. What you need is access to the same data these services use — plus the state-specific records they don't share with families. Tennessee's Health Facilities Commission, CMS Medicare ratings, and the state Abuse Registry are all publicly accessible. The challenge isn't getting the data; it's knowing how to read it and what red flags to look for.

Here's the independent evaluation framework, step by step.

Step 1: Start with CMS Five-Star Ratings — But Don't Stop There

Medicare's Care Compare tool (medicare.gov/care-compare) assigns every certified nursing home a 1-to-5 star overall rating based on health inspections, staffing data, and quality measures. Start here for a quick filter: eliminate any facility rated 1 or 2 stars unless you're in a rural area with limited options.

But the Five-Star rating has well-documented limitations. It averages across three categories, which means a facility with excellent staffing but poor inspection results can still show 3 stars. And the staffing data is self-reported by facilities — CMS only audits a fraction.

The real evaluation starts with Tennessee's own records.

Step 2: Check the Health Facilities Commission Database

The Tennessee Health Facilities Commission (HFC) is the sole licensing and regulatory body for nursing homes in the state. Their website (tn.gov/hfc) maintains the official licensing status, survey results, and enforcement actions for every facility.

What to look for:

• Current license status — active, provisional, or revoked. A provisional license means the facility failed to meet standards and is operating under corrective conditions.
• Survey deficiency reports — these are the detailed findings from state inspections. Look for severity tags: "G" level and above indicate actual harm to residents or immediate jeopardy. Multiple "G" or higher tags in consecutive surveys is a serious red flag.
• Civil monetary penalties — fines imposed for violations. The dollar amount reflects the severity and duration of the deficiency.

Step 3: Pull the FAAR Reports

The HFC publishes monthly Facility Action and Abuse Reports (FAAR) that list every enforcement action taken against licensed facilities in the prior month — citations, penalties, license suspensions, and abuse findings. These reports capture recent incidents that haven't yet been reflected in the CMS Five-Star ratings, which update on a lag.

FAAR reports are dense PDF documents with no consumer-friendly formatting. But they're the most current snapshot of facility safety in Tennessee. Search for the facility name in the most recent 6-12 months of reports.

Step 4: Search the Abuse Registry

Tennessee maintains an Abuse Registry of individuals found to have committed abuse, neglect, or exploitation of vulnerable adults. The registry is searchable online through the HFC. While it lists individuals rather than facilities, checking whether any reported incidents occurred at a facility you're considering provides an additional safety signal.

Step 5: Visit in Person — And Know What to Look For

Desktop research filters out the worst options. On-site visits reveal what the data can't: the smell of the hallways, whether residents are parked in front of televisions or engaged in activities, how staff interact with residents when they think nobody is watching, and whether the facility is clean at 6 PM on a Tuesday (not just during scheduled tours).

Key questions to ask during tours:

• What is the current staff-to-resident ratio, and how does it change on nights and weekends?
• How many TennCare beds does the facility allocate, and is there currently a waitlist?
• What was the most recent HFC survey result, and what deficiencies were cited?
• How does the facility handle involuntary discharge notices?
• What is the complaints process, and how many complaints were filed in the past 12 months?

Step 6: Understand the TennCare CHOICES Nursing Home Path

If your parent will need TennCare CHOICES to pay for nursing home care, the eligibility path has specific requirements:

• Clinical threshold: score of 9 or higher on the 26-point PAE acuity scale
• Financial threshold: income below $2,982/month (or a Qualified Income Trust in place), countable assets below $2,000
• Enrollment group: nursing home care falls under CHOICES Group 1, which is an entitlement — meaning clinically and financially qualified individuals are guaranteed placement without a waitlist, unlike Group 2 home and community-based services

Not all nursing homes accept TennCare at the same rate. Ask specifically about the facility's TennCare census and whether they've been reducing TennCare beds in favor of private-pay residents.

Who This Is For

• Families who want to evaluate nursing homes independently rather than through a commission-based referral service
• Adult children managing a parent's placement from out of state who need a structured research protocol
• Families facing a hospital discharge where a social worker has handed them a list of facilities and asked for a ranked preference by tomorrow morning
• Anyone who's toured facilities but doesn't know how to verify the sales pitch against actual inspection records

Who This Is NOT For

• Families looking for assisted living (ACLFs have different licensing — see our home care vs assisted living comparison)
• Parents who don't meet nursing facility level of care (PAE score below 9) and would be better served by home care or an ACLF
• Families who want a placement service to handle the research — CarePatrol and A Place for Mom do this, though their recommendations are shaped by facility commission agreements

The Tradeoff of Going Independent

The advantage is objectivity. No referral service is recommending facilities based on your parent's clinical needs — they're recommending facilities that pay commissions. When you evaluate independently using HFC, CMS, and FAAR data, every facility on your shortlist earned its place through inspection records and quality metrics, not referral fees.

The disadvantage is time. A thorough independent evaluation of three nursing homes — desktop research, records review, and in-person tours — takes 10 to 15 hours. During a hospital discharge crisis, you may not have that window.

The Choosing Care in Tennessee toolkit includes a Facility Vetting Checklist for the desktop research phase (HFC database, Abuse Registry, FAAR reports, CMS Five-Star) and a Facility Tour Comparison Scorecard for rating facilities side by side during visits. The Crisis Roadmap covers the accelerated evaluation process when you have 24 to 72 hours instead of two weeks.

Frequently Asked Questions

Are referral services like A Place for Mom biased?

Yes, structurally. They're free to families because facilities pay them referral commissions — typically one month's rent — for each placement. This means they only recommend facilities in their network, and their network consists of facilities willing to pay commissions. They also primarily cover assisted living and memory care, not nursing homes. They don't assist with TennCare applications or home care coordination.

How often does Tennessee inspect nursing homes?

Federal law requires annual surveys of all Medicare/Medicaid-certified nursing homes, conducted by state survey agencies. In Tennessee, the HFC conducts these surveys, plus complaint investigations as needed. The FAAR reports capture enforcement actions monthly. CMS Five-Star ratings update roughly quarterly based on the most recent survey cycle.

What's the difference between a Tennessee HFC inspection and the CMS Five-Star rating?

The HFC conducts the actual on-site inspections and issues deficiency citations. CMS takes those inspection results, combines them with staffing data and quality measures, and produces the Five-Star summary. The HFC data is more detailed and more current — a facility might receive a serious citation in March that doesn't show up in the CMS rating until June.

Can a nursing home force my parent to leave?

Tennessee law and federal regulations require facilities to provide 30 days written notice before an involuntary discharge, along with specific reasons (nonpayment, clinical need the facility can't meet, safety of other residents, or the resident's condition has improved enough for a lower level of care). Families can appeal through the Long-Term Care Ombudsman program (1-877-236-0013) or request a hearing.

How do I check if a nursing home accepts TennCare?

Call the facility directly and ask how many TennCare CHOICES beds they currently have and whether there's a waitlist. You can also contact TennCare Connect (1-855-259-0701) or your assigned MCO (BlueCare, Wellpoint, or UnitedHealthcare) for a list of participating facilities in your area.

See more Tennessee guides →